In Memory of





Obituary for Betty Ann Caroff (Schuster)

Betty Ann (Schuster) Caroff, 86, of Red Hill passed away peacefully on Thursday, October 20th, 2022. She was the wife of the late Frank Paynkewicz who passed in 2018 and the late James Allen Caroff who passed in 1978. Born in Johnstown, PA, she was the daughter of the late William and Margaret (Wilcox) Schuster. Betty served as CFO for Penn Foundation in Sellersville before retiring in 2004. She was a member of St. John’s Evangelical Lutheran Church, Ridge Valley. She was also a member of the Golden Agers in the Upper Perkiomen Valley, and she volunteered with “Hope” at St. Philip Neri Catholic Church. She was also very active in the Red Hat Society.

She is survived by her sons, Allen Caroff, and his wife Jennifer, of Green Lane, and John J. Caroff and his wife, Bonnie of Quakertown; her grandchildren: Jessica Caroff and her husband Sadik Jawad, Kaitlin Keeler and her husband Maxwell, Ashley Costanzo and her husband Christopher, Cody Caroff and his wife Paige, and Gavin Caroff and his wife, Brooke. She is also survived by her great grandchildren: Savannah, Jameson, Aiden, and Brielle.

All are invited to visit with her family from 10 – 11 am on Friday, October 28 with services in the sanctuary at 11 am at St. John’s Evangelical Lutheran Church, Ridge Valley, 910 Allentown Rd. Sellersville, PA 18960.

In lieu of flowers, contributions are suggested in her memory to Penn Foundation, Donations can be made to Penn Foundation, 807 Lawn Ave, Sellersville, PA 18960. Visit her "Book of Memories" at